1. Home
  2. Cleveland Home Warranty

Best Home Warranty in Cleveland, OH

Updated 10/12/2018

Home warranties provide protection for homeowners when important household appliances and systems break and are no longer under the manufacturer’s warranty. Our partners at Consumer Affairs researched the best home warranty in Cleveland to save you from unexpected costs of repair or replacement.

Powered by
#1 MOST POPULAR
Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty
CALL CHOICE HOME WARRANTY
(844) 603-4235 VISIT WEBSITE
Sponsored Ad Features
  • Available in Cleveland
  • First month free
  • Customizable plans
  • Pre-screened technicians
Read More
#2
American Home Shield
American Home Shield
CALL AMERICAN HOME SHIELD
(855) 463-2405 VISIT WEBSITE
Sponsored Ad Features
  • Build your own plan
  • Multiple coverage options
  • Available in Cleveland
  • 45 years of experience
Read More
#3
TotalProtect
TotalProtect
CALL TOTALPROTECT
(844) 278-1657 VISIT WEBSITE
Sponsored Ad Features
  • Rust & corrosion coverage
  • Pool & spa coverage
  • Pre-screened contractors
  • Available in Cleveland
Read More
#4
Select Home Warranty
Select Home Warranty
CALL SELECT HOME WARRANTY
(844) 334-6081 VISIT WEBSITE
Sponsored Ad Features
  • Available in Cleveland
  • Unlimited covered repairs
  • 24/7 claims
  • No home inspection needed
Read More
#5
First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty
CALL FIRST AMERICAN HOME WARRANTY
(844) 262-7913 VISIT WEBSITE
Sponsored Ad Features
  • Plans start at $28/month
  • Free, online quote
  • Available in Cleveland
  • Flexible payment options
Read More

Everyone deserves to make thoughtful, informed purchase decisions. The local guides provided on this website are free for consumers. News 5 may receive compensation from our partners. Learn more.

Powered by

How we chose the best

ConsumerAffairs thoroughly researched consumer reviews and company information.

16 Hours researched
75 Reviews analyzed
10 Companies evaluated
5 Companies selected
×
#1
#1 MOST POPULAR
Choice Home Warranty

Get a free quote today!

CALL CHOICE HOME WARRANTY
Call now
(844) 797-9755 Visit Choice Home Warranty
Sponsored Ad

Benefits of a home warranty in Cleveland

Cleveland Skyline

A home warranty may be valuable to homebuyers to prevent sudden out-of-pocket expenses. Sellers may use warranty coverage as an incentive to potential buyers. And those with dated appliances or lacking funds for emergency repairs also benefit. Cleveland has a large number of older homes with a higher likelihood of system failures. Our long winters with snow, ice and freezing temperatures only add to that risk.

Most home warranties cover large appliances and systems, such as heating, electrical and plumbing. Others may include water tanks, kitchen appliances and roofs. Most policies are customizable to the buyer’s specific needs, such as swimming pools, well-pumping systems and laundry machines.

In the first two years after purchase, about 66 percent of homeowners need repairs or replacement of two systems or appliances. New homeowners can exhaust significant financial resources on down payments, moving costs and new furnishings, and not have money left over to repair expensive household systems.

Home warranties are no substitute for homeowners insurance. Home warranties cover systems and appliances that eventually need service or replacement. Homeowner’s insurance covers damage from fire, accidents or weather-related events, not for damage from wear and tear.

Home warranty costs per year
Location Average price Range
Cleveland $841 $425 - $1,257
Ohio $882 $882 - $1,308
Nationwide $841 $216 - $1,468
Pittsburgh $600 $300 - $900
Columbus $1,203 $685 - $1,721

Warranty costs depend on the scope of items covered and the size and type of home. A service fee normally applies when filing a claim. Policies should clearly state the amount that policyholders are to pay, similar to a co-pay or deductible. Always read the policy agreement terms, including which items are covered and any deductible or payments required for service calls.

Home warranty companies in Cleveland usually determine who handles repair work by using contractors in their network. Some homeowners dislike being unable to choose while others prefer the convenience of having the provider facilitate repairs.

Choice Home Warranty

Choice Home Warranty (844) 603-4235

CALL CHOICE HOME WARRANTY

A well-established network of Cleveland technicians at Choice Home Warranty provides fast and quality service for homeowners. Online reviews say that the company tends to correct problems quickly. The majority of negative reviews are from confusion about what items are covered (or not) under the warranty agreement.

VISIT CHOICE HOME WARRANTY
Sponsored Ad

American Home Shield

American Home Shield (855) 463-2405

CALL AMERICAN HOME SHIELD

American Home Shield has issued home warranties to over 1.7 million people over the last 45 years. Cleveland customers say that they are a good provider for those who are busy and appreciate the ease and convenience of having AHS identify the problem and solve it in a timely manner.

VISIT AMERICAN HOME SHIELD
Sponsored Ad

TotalProtect

TotalProtect (844) 278-1657

CALL TOTALPROTECT

With a network of 40,000 qualified service technicians, TotalProtect gives a six-month guarantee on its work. Satisfied customers say they continue to use them as their provider for many years, although some reviews cite concerns about the quality of customer service.

VISIT TOTALPROTECT
Sponsored Ad

Select Home Warranty

Select Home Warranty (844) 334-6081

CALL SELECT HOME WARRANTY

Select Home Warranty has three unique warranty packages available for homeowners with different needs. Their claim service works 24/7; however, the company gets mixed reviews with some people feeling that their claims were unfairly denied for various reasons.

VISIT SELECT HOME WARRANTY
Sponsored Ad

First American Home Warranty

First American Home Warranty (844) 262-7913

CALL FIRST AMERICAN HOME WARRANTY

Customers can conveniently file a service request on the website of First American Home Warranty, which has been in business since 1984. Customer reviews say how great their responsiveness is to service requests. One local real estate veteran of 16 years explained in a review that First American has been a consistently good option over the years.

VISIT FIRST AMERICAN HOME WARRANTY
Sponsored Ad

Our partners independently research and analyze the companies mentioned in our guides and work with subject matter experts to add valuable information that helps consumers make smart purchase decisions. Our partners will not include companies on these guides that do not meet specific quality standards. The compensation we receive from our partners may impact how and where companies appear on our site, including the order in which they appear.

Our partners independently research companies, and use editorial discretion to award companies with special recognition (i.e. Best Value) based on their staff’s judgement or subject matter expert’s judgement. Our partners do this to help you identify companies that will meet your specific buying needs, and do not receive compensation for these designations.